• Español
  • English
  • facebook
  • twitter
  • rss
  • Español
  • English
  • facebook
  • twitter
  • rss
TNI D&D
  • Home
  • About us
    • About us
    • People
    • Partners
    • Researchers
    • Contact us
    • In the media
    • Newsletter
  • Newsroom
    • Press contacts
    • Press releases
    • Resources
    • Drugs in the news
  • Issues
    • Drug policy debate in the Americas
    • Decriminalization
    • Proportionality of sentences
    • Harm reduction
    • Reclassification of substances
    • Safer crack use
    • Human rights
    • Regulation
    • Unscheduling the coca leaf
    • Ending the war on drugs
    • Alternative development
    • Cannabis
    • Producers of Crops
    • Law enforcement
    • ATS, Mild stimulants & NPS
    • European Drug Policy
    • Money Laundering
  • UN Drug
    Control
    • Conventions
    • UNODC
    • CND
    • INCB
    • UNGASS
  • Country
    information
    • Drug Law Reform on the Map
    • Central America
      • El Salvador
      • Guatemala
      • Honduras
      • Costa Rica
    • Latin America
      • Argentina
      • Bolivia
      • Paraguay
      • Brazil
      • Chile
      • Colombia
      • Ecuador
      • Peru
      • Uruguay
      • Venezuela
    • Mexico
    • Caribbean
      • Jamaica
      • Belize
    • Afghanistan
  • Events
    • Expert Seminars
    • Informal Policy Dialogues
    • Public Events
    • Judges for Law Reform
  • Publications
    • Drug Policy Briefings
    • Drug Law Reform
    • Legislative Reform Series
    • The Human Face
    • Drugs & conflict
    • Drugs and the Law (CEDD)
      • Systems overload
    • Drug Markets and Violence
  • Weblog

 

Flexibility of treaty provisions

In a confidential and authoritative memorandum to the INCB, UNODC legal experts argue that most harm reduction measures are in fact acceptable under the conventions. According to the Legal Affairs Section "it could easily be argued that the Guiding Principles of Drug Demand Reduction provide a clear mandate for the institution of harm reduction policies that, respecting cultural and gender differences, provide for a more supportive environment for drug users."

Read the full legal advice (pdf): Flexibility of Treaty Provisions as Regards Harm Reduction Approaches, Prepared by the Legal Affairs Section, E/INCB/2002/W.13/SS.5, 30 September 2002 (RESTRICTED)

On methadone substitution treatment the UNODC experts say that it "could hardly be perceived as contrary to the text or the spirit of the treaties. It is a commonly accepted addiction treatment, with several advantages and few drawbacks. Although results are mixed and dependent on many factors, its implementation along sound medical practice guidelines would not constitute a breach of treaty provisions."

On needle- or syringe-exchange the document says that this is a "rather straightforward strategy to reduce the risk of contagion with communicable diseases to IV drug abusers [intravenous] who share needles or syringes. It has been introduced in many countries around the world, to help reduce the rate of intravenous transmission of HIV and other transmittable diseases."

About drug-injection rooms, the legal advice given is that "even supplying a drug addict with the drug he depends on could be seen as a sort of rehabilitation and social reintegration, assuming that once his drug requirements are taken care of, he will not need to involve himself in criminal activities to finance his dependence" and that it "would be difficult to assert that, in establishing drug-injection rooms, it is the intent of Parties to actually incite to or induce the illicit use of drugs, or even more so, to associate with, aid, abet or facilitate the possession of drugs. [..] On the contrary, it seems clear that in such cases the intention of governments is to provide healthier conditions for IV drug abusers, thereby reducing their risk of infection with grave transmittable diseases and, at least in some cases, reaching out to them with counselling and other therapeutic options. Albeit how insufficient this may look from a demand reduction point of view, it would still fall far from the intent of committing an offence as foreseen in the 1988 Convention."

Finally, addressing the remaining doubts about a potential tense legal footing of some treaty articles with harm reduction, the document states, refering to the HIV/AIDS crisis: "It could even be argued that the drug control treaties, as they stand, have been rendered out of synch with reality, since at the time they came into force they could not have possibly foreseen these new threats."

 
  • Labels
    2005 CND debate | conventions | UNODC | INCB | harm reduction

Drugs in the News

  • Appeals Court overturns ruling that legalized SCS; Safehouse fights on
    13.01.2021
  • Mexico moves to create world’s largest legal cannabis market
    12.01.2021
  • Cuomo vows New York 'will legalize adult-use recreational cannabis'
    11.01.2021
  • Blown off: Amsterdam will ban foreign tourists from coffeeshops in future
    08.01.2021
  • CDC and NIDA will finally study potential of safe consumption sites
    07.01.2021
  • The top cannabis research studies of 2020
    07.01.2021
More news

Weblog

    A new EU Drug Strategy is being repared by the German presidencyA new EU Drug Strategy is being repared by the German presidency
    08.10.2020
More weblog

Hilites

Balancing Treaty Stability and Change

balancing hilite

Inter se modification of the UN drug control conventions to facilitate cannabis regulation


Connecting the dots...

connecting dots hilite

Human rights, illicit cultivation and alternative development


Morocco and Cannabis

morocco cannabis hilite

Reduction, containment or acceptance


The Rise and Decline of Cannabis Prohibition

rise decline hilite

The History of Cannabis in the UN Drug Control System and Options For Reform


Tags

10-year Review  20 1998 UNGASS  26 2005 CND debate  8 2016 UNGASS  126 2019 HLM  5 activism  19 afghanistan  24 show all

Tags

10-year Review  20 1998 UNGASS  26 2005 CND debate  8 2016 UNGASS  126 2019 HLM  5 activism  19 afghanistan  24 hide
africa  7 albania  11 alternative development  112 alternatives to policing  2 amnesty  61 appellation of origin  3 argentina  32 asean  9 ATS  15 australia  93 ayahuasca  5 bahamas  4 ballot 2012  155 banking  43 barbados  11 belgium  32 belize  10 bermuda  4 bolivia  115 brazil  92 brownfield doctrine  24 burma  42 california  199 cambodia  12 canada  492 cannabinoids  88 cannabis  2753 cannabis clubs  185 cannabis industry  362 caribbean  133 caricom  33 cbd oil  1 central america  5 chile  21 china  46 civil society  37 CND  126 coca  212 cocaine  59 coffee shop  210 cognitive decline  30 colombia  147 colorado  159 compulsary detention  19 conflict  3 conventions  249 corporate capture  6 costa rica  10 crack  50 craft cannabis  27 crime  67 czech republic  30 dark net  4 death penalty  2 decertification  1 decriminalization  813 deforestation  8 denmark  119 drug checking  35 drug consumption rooms  176 drug courts  22 drug markets  133 drug testing  7 drug trade  48 e-cigarettes  1 e-joint  2 ecstasy  59 ecuador  22 egypt  16 el salvador  2 environment  14 eradication  125 essential medicines  25 estonia  1 eswatini  4 european drug policy  67 expert advisory group  9 extrajudicial killings  92 fair trade  13 fentanyl  74 france  96 fumigation  25 gateway theory  29 georgia  2 germany  151 ghana  16 global commission  46 greece  18 guatemala  31 guatemala initiative  47 harm reduction  329 hemp  39 heroin  126 heroin assisted treatment  77 HIV/AIDS  61 home cultivation  72 honduras  3 human rights  246 incarceration  51 INCB  135 india  87 indonesia  32 informal drug policy dialogues  22 inter se modification  13 iran  14 ireland  15 israel  55 italy  34 jamaica  161 japan  2 kava  3 kazakhstan  5 ketamine  27 khat  36 kratom  26 kyrgyzstan  1 laos  2 latin american debate  115 law enforcement  377 lebanon  41 legal highs  63 legalization  1346 lesotho  6 luxembourg  32 malaysia  7 malta  13 medical cannabis  594 mental health  43 methamphetamine  40 mexico  201 Mid-Term Review  1 mild stimulants  37 money laundering  53 morocco  88 naloxone  12 nepal  6 netherlands  285 new york  20 new zealand  64 NIDA  5 nitrous oxide  6 norway  15 NPS  10 opinion polls  115 opioids  129 opium  90 oregon  29 overdose kits  4 pakistan  9 panama  5 paraguay  4 pardon  2 patents  18 peace  22 peru  41 peyote  3 philippines  85 pleasure  5 police pacification  18 portugal  66 potency  2 precursors  6 prevention  3 prison situation  92 producers  117 prohibition  140 proportionality  110 psychedelics  11 psychosis  53 puerto rico  3 racism  24 reclassification  116 recriminalisation  36 regulation  1187 russia  36 sacramental use  11 safe supply  18 safer crack  28 scheduling  24 scientific research  135 sdg  2 security  14 senegal  1 sentencing  65 singapore  6 social justice  47 south africa  62 spain  76 st lucia  7 st vincent and grenadines  29 substance-use disorder  18 substitution treatment  30 sweden  26 switzerland  133 synthetic cannabinoids  30 taxation  38 teen use  43 thailand  52 thresholds  37 tramadol  17 treatment  22 trinidad & tobago  14 tunisia  5 UK  247 UN drug control  422 UNGASS  58 UNODC  107 uruguay  143 US drug policy  1105 vaping  2 venezuela  5 vietnam  5 violence  131 WHO  60 world drug report  11

This website

UN Drug Control

In 2011 the 1961 UN Single Convention on drugs will be in place for 50 years. In 2012 the international drug control system will exist 100 years since the International Opium Convention was signed in 1912 in The Hague. Does it still serve its purpose or is a reform of the UN Drug Conventions needed? This site provides critical background.

Drug Law Reform on the map

dlronthemap_und

Copyright © 2016 Drug Law Reform in Latin America

Website by WebWolf